Reuben Tour of Columbus – Katalina’s Cafe Corner

After a long layoff, the search for the best reuben in Columbus continues. As mentioned in the last post, I had to head closer to downtown to find a more traditional reuben.

Thanks to some positive Yelp reviews, I decided to head to Victorian Village to check out Katalina’s Cafe Corner. Here’s the scorecard:

Corned beef – warm, but only three or four slices, kinda skimpy
Sauerkraut – generous amount
Swiss Cheese – plenty of cheese, gooey
Thousand Island – on the sandwich, good amount
Rye Bread – marbled, nice big pieces, fresh

Katalina’s Cafe Corner scores 4 out of 5. A few more slices of corned beef, and this would go from really good to great. Katalina’s has a really diverse and interesting menu, looking forward to going back to try out more of their offerings.